CHI '97 Design Briefings:
Meta-Review Form
==================================================
BEGIN: META-REVIEW FORM FOR CHI 97 DESIGN BRIEFINGS
==================================================
INSTRUCTIONS
1. This form should be filled out and
returned by email (as ASCII text, not
as an attached document) to Tom Erickson,
the CHI '97 Design Briefings Co-Chair, at
thomas@apple.com
2. The deadline is Wednesday, October 30,
1996. PLEASE be prompt. If for any reason
you're going to miss your deadline PLEASE
inform the Co-Chair at once (thomas@apple.com)
3. Enter your ratings and/or comments within the
pairs of angle brackets, << >>: <<Like this>>
4. You should treat the design briefings and
their reviews and meta-reviews as confidential
materials, not to be discussed outside the
CHI reviewing process.
5. Please see the Associate Chairs Guidelines
document for more information.
META-REVIEWER NUMBER: << >>
DESIGN BRIEFING NUMBER: << >>
DESIGN BRIEFING TITLE: << >>
1. Briefly SUMMARIZE the design briefing:
<< >>
2. Please summarize the reasons why CHI 97
should ACCEPT the submission:
<< >>
3. Please summarize the reasons why CHI 97
should REJECT the submission:
<< >>
4. Please write your recommendation about
why CHI 97 should either ACCEPT or REJECT
the submission. That is, please consider
what you wrote in items 2 and 3, and come
to your own conclusion about the submission:
<< >>
5. Please summarize your recommendation
as a number from 1-5, where
1 = Definitely REJECT
2 = Probably REJECT
3 = Could go EITHER WAY
4 = Probably ACCEPT
5 = Definitely ACCEPT
<< >>
6. Please write any other comments you think
would be useful to the authors:
<< >>
***********************************************
7. Please write any PRIVATE comments that you
would like to make to the program co-chairs.
These comments WILL NOT be shared with the
AUTHORS. If these comments should NOT be
shared with the initial reviewers, please
state your restriction clearly:
<< >>
==================================================
END: META-REVIEW FORM FOR CHI 97 DESIGN BRIEFINGS
==================================================